• About
    • About The Absenger Cancer Education Foundation
    • ACEF Focus: Education of Public and Health Care Providers
    • ACEF Focus: Integrating Mind-Body Medicine & Survivorship
    • ACEF Focus: Mind-Body Medicine Research in West Michigan
    • Absenger Cancer Education Foundation Membership Model
  • Governance
    • Our Board
      • Sally Zarafonetis, CEO SallyZara
      • Wendy Borden, M.S., M.S.
      • Mark Blough, Psy.D.
      • Kathy Blough, Psy.S.
      • Francisco Munoz, PI “Coping with Cancer II” Study
      • Alexzandria Baker, M.S., Ph.D.(c)
    • Our CEO
    • Our Team
      • Alex
      • Lisa
      • Dawn
      • Nancy
      • Karri
  • Press
  • Membership
  • Giving
  • Blog
  • Contact

Absenger Cancer Education Foundation | ACEF

Helping cancer survivors feel better with yoga, meditation & qigong

Create The Life That YOU Love with MindBodyMed!

  • Meditation
    • What is Meditation?
    • Meditation & Cancer Articles
  • Yoga
    • Yoga & Cancer Articles
  • Stress
    • 8 Reasons Why You Benefit From Cancer Support Groups
  • Mindful Eating
    • Mindful Eating: Answer to Obesity & Cancer?
    • Nutrition
      Consult
      • How to Find the Perfect Diet For Cancer Patients
      • Nutrition & Cancer Articles
  • Classes
    • Find a Meditation Class
    • Find a Yoga Class
    • See All Events
  • Videos & Audio
You are here: Home / Homeopathy & Cancer / The Homeopathic Research of David Reilly, M.D.

The Homeopathic Research of David Reilly, M.D.

July 17, 2006 by Werner Absenger

What do three positives in a row mean?

Here is an interesting paper documenting Dr. Reilly’s research on homeopathy. He performed a study three times because he thought each previous result to be tarnished in some way. Turns out that with this approach the authors concluded: “Either homeopathy works or controlled clinical trials do not.” Read the details about the study, sorry, the three studies, below.

David Reilly, M.D of Glasgow Medical University was elected to the Royal College of Physicians and surgeons, one of Britain’s highest medical honors.

He became interested in hypnosis and inner mind work, but had to put it aside until he describes reaching a crisis point. He says his first water in the desert was through the British Society of medical and dental hypnosis where he took some postgraduate courses. He was thrilled to bring together in a systematic way, some of the ideas that he had previously studied and spontaneously applied with his patients.

He sees an ad for a position of registrar at the Glasgow homeopathic hospital and applies for it knowing very little about homeopathy. He says he has no confidence in the dilutions, but he was very interested in the system of care.

He liked the feeling of the hospital. There was an open-minded feeling about the hospital. The doctors seemed more “flexible” there.

He believed that to shift a culture’s medical views he would have to publish research in the most prestigious journal.

He chose to study the treatment of hay fever and pollen, because most people understood that you can give pollen shots to combat pollen allergies. The only new concept was the one of the dilution. He designed the study with the input of his most skeptical colleagues, because he thought it important to consult your enemies rather than your best friends and try to understand where they’re coming from.

When the pilot study worked, he confesses he was shocked. He had believed all along that the dilutions were merely placebo. When it came out positive, his gut feeling was, “this has got to be a mistake”. They submitted the pilot study to the Lancet (it was rejected) so they took on criticisms from every forum they could gather, incorporated some changes and re-ran the study, but made it 5 times bigger. They took drastic measures to protect the study from fraud, hired a neutral statistician. The results again were positive. They re-submitted it and it was published in The Lancet.

Criticism started to roll in “Who cares about hay fever”? “It had nothing to do with hay fever.” (The criticism was about the research being about homeopathy!) He had now tainted his reputation as a homeopathic researcher.

.

Reilly then approached the head of respiratory medicine at Glasgow University and asked him if he would like to be the man who disproves homeopathy. I have the grant!

This time they studied asthma and its allergen trigger house dust-mites. This time they studied conventional patients with conventional researcher, included lab tests and histamine provocation. The remedies were made in France sent straight to the pharmacists, double blinded, who recorded them and administered them to patients.

Within 7 days of receiving the remedy, the patients showed a clinically and statistically documented drop in symptoms.

A cultural debate ensued as to wheatears the clinical trial evidence was proving sufficient to validate an unconventional therapy. A review was published after 100 trials of homeopathy, with 77% showing results in favor of the therapy. Reilly began to ask “would 200 trials be evidence would 300 trials be evidence?

What do three positives in a row mean? Either we have shown that homeopathy works and that it works more than placebo, or we’ve determined that the clinical trial doesn’t work!

Details of Reilly’s asthma study:

He was able to get around the subjective problems that arise in case taking by designing a study that used conventional allergy testing to determine what substances the subjects were most allergic to. The subjects then chosen for treatment were given the 30c potency of the substance they were sensitive to. They were then evaluated by both homeopathic doctors and conventional doctors. The study showed that 82% of the patients given a homeopathic medicine improved. Only 38 % of Placebo receivers experienced a similar degree of relief. When asked if they felt the patient received the hom. Remedy or the placebo, both the patients and the doctors tended to guess correctly.

The experiment was relatively small- 24 patients. The smaller the sample size, the larger the difference must be between those treated with medicine and those given placebo.

One interesting aspect of Reilly’s studies was the meta-analysis , reviewing the data from all three studies on allergic conditions, which totaled 202 subjects. The researchers found a similar pattern in all three studies. Improvement began in the first week and continued through the end of the trial four weeks later. The results of this meta-analysis were so substantial, (P=0.0004) that the authors concluded that either homeopathy works or controlled clinical trials do not.

The amount of scrutiny and critism that surfaces when there is a positive study about homeopathy is absurd. After the Lancet published Reilly’s third study, there was still no acknowledgement that homeopathy works, and there was even a statement that conventional medicine works better. A strange statement considering that the experiment did not test homeopathy against conventional medicine. Dana Ullman said about it, “If we proved a person could fly, they would respond: Well a jet plane can still fly higher and faster.”

Beste Gesundheit,

Werner

References:

Mosby’s (2004) Mosby’s Complementary & Alternative Medicine: A Research-Based Approach St. Louis pg. 384-385.

Ullman D. (1991) Discovering Homeopathy: Medicine for the 21st Century Berkeley: North Atlantic Books. pg. 55-56

Filed Under: Homeopathy & Cancer Tagged With: a;ternative medicine blog, Adolf & Maria Absenger Cancer Foundation, AMACF, glasgow, Werner Absenger

Donate

Donate to our program. Because spreading knowledge of treatments that ease stress, anxiety, depression, and pain can't wait. You can make a small $7 donation by clicking here.

ACEF-donate-today

The Absenger Cancer Education Foundation (ACEF) is a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt organization.

Disclaimer

Be smart about integrating mind-body medicine and nutrition when living with chronic disease and/or in cancer survivorship. Never delay seeking medical advice, disregard medical advice, or discontinue medical treatment because of information on this website.

Moreover, please, always inform your primary health care provider and/or oncologist about the wonderful things you are doing at ACEF. This will ensure that you achieve optimum quality of life in your survivorship and/or while living with chronic disease. Thank you.

About Werner Absenger

I am committed to helping you make the most out of your cancer survivorship experience. Extended Bio...

YOUR HEALTH IS IN NEED OF A LITTLE TLC, RIGHT? LET'S MAKE IT BETTER!

You can't get better without making some changes. We'll show you how li'l changes can get you to feel better and awesomer.

We will never sell, rent, or share your email.

About Werner Absenger

Werner Absenger

Werner is the founder of the Absenger Cancer Education Foundation (ACEF) a 501(c)(3) not for profit organization. He helps empower and improve the quality of life of West Michigan’s cancer survivors, their loved ones, caregivers, and people living with chronic disease. This goal is accomplished through research, education, and integration of evidence-based nutrition and mind-body modalities. Continue reading...

Donate

Make a small donation to support the work of ACEF's experts in West Michigan. You can immediately show your support by clicking here.

ACEF-donate-today

The Absenger Cancer Education Foundation (ACEF) is a qualified 501(c)(3) tax-exempt organization.

Popular Posts & Pages

  • Mindfulness and the Stages of Grief in Chronic Disease
    Mindfulness and the Stages of Grief in Chronic Disease
  • The Homeopathic Research of David Reilly, M.D.
    The Homeopathic Research of David Reilly, M.D.
  • Characteristics of a Healthful Diet
    Characteristics of a Healthful Diet
  • Bhattacharjee & Khuda-Bukhsh. (2012). Two Homeopathic Remedies Provide Protective Effects Against Hepatotoxicity Induced by Carcinogens…
    Bhattacharjee & Khuda-Bukhsh. (2012). Two Homeopathic Remedies Provide Protective Effects Against Hepatotoxicity Induced by Carcinogens…
  • Women with Cancer Thwart Vaginal Dryness Using Personal Lubricants
    Women with Cancer Thwart Vaginal Dryness Using Personal Lubricants
  • Pancreatic Cancer: Seaweed’s Secret Cancer Fighting Benefits
    Pancreatic Cancer: Seaweed’s Secret Cancer Fighting Benefits
  • ACEF's Mindful Eating and Living (MEAL) Class
    ACEF's Mindful Eating and Living (MEAL) Class
  • 9 Reasons Yoga Makes Life Better for Breast Cancer Survivors
    9 Reasons Yoga Makes Life Better for Breast Cancer Survivors
  • Sally's Focus: Raise Awareness of Holistic Health Care
    Sally's Focus: Raise Awareness of Holistic Health Care
  • Yoga Therapy Program for Self Care in Cancer Survivorship
    Yoga Therapy Program for Self Care in Cancer Survivorship

Search The Absenger Cancer Education Foundation’s Site

Donate to our program. Because spreading knowledge of treatments that ease stress, anxiety, depression, and pain can't wait. You can make a small $7 donation by clicking here.

ACEF-donate-button-small

The Absenger Cancer Education Foundation (ACEF) is a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt organization.

National Institutes of Health Links

National Cancer Institute (NCI)
National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH)
Office of Cancer Complementary and Alternative Medicine (OCCAM)
Office of Cancer Survivorship (OCS)

Open Access Journals

PubMed.gov
The Oncologist
PLOS one
BioMedCentral Cancer (BMC)
Complementary and Alternative Medicine (BMC)
The Journal of Mind-Body Regulation
Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine (eCAM)

Get Help Locally

The Revive & Thrive Project
Gilda's Club GR
Mary Free Bed Cancer Rehabilitation
Mercy Health Johnson Family Cancer Center
The Cancer Center at Metro Health Village
Lemmen-Holton Cancer Pavilion
Helen DeVos Children’s Hospital
Comfort Keepers

You made it all the way down here... So you probably want more great tips from us on how to make the best out of your survivorship experience...

about us

Our Mission & Vision
Our Board
Our CEO
Our Team

Ways to Give

Reveal Your Inner Hero: Subdue Suffering Offline Form (PDF)

ACEF donate button

The Absenger Cancer Education Foundation (ACEF) is a 501(c)(3) public charity. Your gift may qualify as a charitable deduction for federal income tax purposes. Please consult with your tax adviser or the IRS to determine whether your contribution is deductible.

Copyright © 2006-2015 The Absenger Cancer Education Foundation. All rights reserved.
17212 Van Wagoner Road | Suite A | Spring Lake, MI 49456 | Contact Us | Legal Disclaimer | Privacy Policy